I'm responsible for educating landowners and loggers about water quality. Over the years, I developed a mnemonic device for remembering the 5 components of an effective "water bar"... or rather a "WADDA" bar:
W - Width: make sure the soil berm is the full width of the trail
A - Angle: the soil berm should be angled slightly across the trail so water hitting it will slow down and be diverted off trail.
D- Depth: establish a trough that will capture water flow on the trail. If the water bar is too shallow, it will not be effective beyond the first couple rainstorms.
D - "Dig It": the trough of a water bar functions best when it is dug into the subsoil or soil hardpan of the trail.
A - Anticipate the use: ask landowners how they use their trails (pickup truck, atv, etc) and make water bar design changes to accommodate.